Slice of Life Day 18. Join the Two Writing Teachers Slice of Life Challenge.
I follow middle grade authors on Facebook, Twitter, and on their blogs. Recently, Caroline Starr Rose, author of May B, posted a book give-away on her blog for Crystal Chan’s book Bird. And I won! The book arrived with a sweet note from Crystal Chan. Her note said, “Please tell about it–that’s the best way to give Bird a strong tail wind for its first flight.” Already I knew I would love this book. Then I read the first line, “My grandpa stopped speaking the day he killed my brother.”
I have not written book reviews, ever. I hate to admit this. I’m supposed to be a writer. For some reason, this kind of writing has intimidated me. But when I got this book and Crystal’s note, I knew I had to give it a try. I talked to my student Vannisa about this review. She read Bird. I told her we would write the review together. There is a sense of safety in collaborative writing, and Vannisa had some good insights about the theme that I hadn’t even thought of.
Vannisa googled writing book reviews and made a list of steps for us to follow. She checked them off as we completed each one. I love how we had a role reversal here. Now she wants to read A Snicker of Magic with me. So maybe we will write more reviews together.
I posted this review on Goodreads, my first! I want to publicly thank Crystal Chan for this wonderful gift, her words, her character Jewel, and her touching story.
Crystal Chan has successfully written the saddest first page ever. She draws us in to the life of 12 year old Jewel who was born on the day her brother died. So her birthday is always a day of grief for her parents and grandpa. Jewel has never heard her grandpa speak because he stopped talking on that fateful day.
Jewel’s life changes the day she meets a boy in a tree. His name is John just like her late brother. Coincidence or not?
Crystal Chan leads us on a journey of action and emotion. I felt like I had been betrayed as Jewel overhears her parents arguing.
“I was never wanted. Not even the moment I was coming into the world.”
Jewel’s friendship with John may be a coincidence or a sign. Her grandfather believes it is a curse on her family, but Jewel believes it is good luck. Jewel sees a bit of herself in John. They both dream about their future; Jewel wants to be a geologist and John wants to be an astronaut. Mixed in this enchanting story are facts about the Jamaican culture and the universe.
You just want to read Bird again, to climb trees again, and to dream of a better life.
Great review, and how fun you composed it with help from a student! You certainly made me want to read it. 🙂
Thanks for sharing this book review with us. What an intriguing story. I will definitely check it out. I once was chosen to lead a book group discussion on GoodReads which I felt intimidated to accept. What was crazier, was that after the discussion, the author contacted me and sent me some bookplates that she had hand drawn. Ridiculously generous!! So fun.
Here’s the book, The Calligrapher’s Daughter by Eugenia Kim
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6400109-the-calligrapher-s-daughter?from_search=true
Thanks for sharing, and taking a risk. You now have me intrigued and i will add i to my “to read” list. (My library doesn’t have it. I just checked). It’s nice to work with someone when you are trying something new. Stepping out together is always easier than stepping out alone.
I’m excited to read this, Margaret & will read all your review after I finish, but love that you are collaborating with your students. What a wonderful thing for her and for you. I keep hearing about this book, have bought it, so can’t wait! Also I keep hearing about A Snicker of Magic-2 good books already this year!
Your amazing reading and reviews have inspired me. Thanks.
I certainly do not think this should be your one and only book review! And what fun that you wrote it with your student! This sounds like my kind of book and I have added it to my amazon cart.
Thanks. Now Bird will fly to you. Let me know what you think.
Awesome review, I’d love to read more! This sounds like a really intense book, but also a good one. I’ll definitely add this to my never ending list of “to read” books!
Wonderful review – so makes me want to read the book! What a great collaboration to have with your student – for both of you. Will look forward to lots more!
So much to learn from our students–you demonstrate well. Oh, how embarrassed I was when a student showed me how to right click using two fingers on my Mac laptop I had had for several months or when the student revealed to me the autofocus button on my doc camera. And you changed roles, with your student as the writing expert–beautiful!